8mm Forum: Digital Transfers, where to start?

This is topic Digital Transfers, where to start? in forum 8mm Forum at 8mm Forum.

To visit this topic, use this URL:
https://8mmforum.film-tech.com/cgi-bin/ubb/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=1;t=012753

Posted by Richard Holloway (Member # 6832) on January 30, 2019, 09:38 AM:

I need to transfer probably 5000 or —6000 feet of film to digital. I have both 8mm and Super 8 on 3, 5, and 8” reels. All old family films I’d prefer to help in my direct custody.

Some were transferred to video tape about 25 years ago with marginal results. What are my realistic options? Is there a good thread to follow? The Wolverine sounds like it’s of questionable quality. Are there better quality, perhaps used systems around for a bit more? I can’t afford the $5000 range systems.

Do used setups of better quality get resold after people transfer a big batch of work? Can you rent a higher quality system for a month or two somewhere?

Posted by Mike Spice (Member # 5957) on January 30, 2019, 10:54 AM:

You will see recent posts talking about the Wolverine damaging film, that's not good, that is actually quite upsetting.

I have a 720p wolverine and have made some quite amazing video files, it hasn't been an easy road, but none of my film has been damaged, I have had many issues with the scanner along the way.

I still use my Wolverine and get some great results... I have scanned many thousands of feet for other people, charging a rock bottom price, and they too, have all been happy with the result.

Reading in this forum, you will see one two or three wolverines being returned in an outrage of disgust because it has simply not done what was asked of it.

Commercial scanning is expensive but the results are quite something.

I have edited out around 600ft of 'precious moments' super 8 I want scanned on a proper HD scanner and I am looking at around £100/200 depending on which house I choose to do the work.

Many people strive to save films using all sorts of contraptions and produce some amazing results...

Reading through this forum it is easy to get the opinion the Wolverine is nothing short of a disgrace and while I would agree in part, I have achieved some amazing results over the last year or so.

It's a tough decision, blow £400 on a chinese cheap scanner, or spend that £400 wisely, by editing out the seriously precious parts of your films, with the 'family' shots and not the 'back garden' shots, and let someone else do it for you, without the fuss, and get some stunning expensive hassle free results.

Perhaps spend some time with a projector and video camera and see what sort of results you can achieve at home, many people do that with some surprisingly very good results, but it is a very time consuming hobby to get right.

I have never heard of anyone renting a 'proper' scanner

If I was starting all over again, I would choose the 'edit out the precious moments' to a couple of reels and have a house scan it for you properly.

If you did choose that route, don't get a dvd made, go blu ray and make sure you get video files on a usb device.

Standard 8mm scanned on my 720p Wolverine, no picture enhancement

[ January 31, 2019, 10:52 AM: Message edited by: Mike Spice ]

Posted by Jake Mayes (Member # 3292) on January 30, 2019, 11:21 AM:

Some labs can get 2K worth of quality out, if your willing to pay for it.

If you MUST use a wolverine (i do not recommend, just has a positive print of a family do damaged big time, luckily i had a negative to go back to and it is on it's way to andec now for a new positive print) USE FILMGUARD if you wish to protect your originals. No ifs or buts, please be careful.

Your other option is a custom telecine machine you make yourself, or drip feed your film to a lab that can do 2K scans, like on8mil in london, though find an equiv in the US.

What is your budget? What sort of quality do you want? The scans of the wolverine are not half bad, it was the damaging film and jitter issue that put me off it and lead to me opening a return case.

Posted by Mike Spice (Member # 5957) on January 30, 2019, 11:24 AM:

There you go, a Wolverine user who has had to put up with damaged film....

It really is a conundrum.

I will defend my 720p wolverine that has never damaged an inch of mine, or my customers films.

It really is a game of dice and patience with the Wolverine.

Posted by Bill Sherren (Member # 6743) on January 30, 2019, 12:26 PM:

I wonder if the Velcro tabs that the Pro has just before and after the gate has helped to contribute to this damage? The earlier Wolverine models don't have this from what I can see.. Also they changed the white tabs that hold the film in place on the most recent Wolverine Pro models. Each of these changes might have different effects good or bad to the footage and its handling. My Wolverine never worked from out the box starting with a loud knocking sound when first used. This did disappear after the first scan but not a good start! 90% of the scans are unstable either at the top or the whole image. The exposure caused a flickering effect on many scenes. Choosing the low sharpness setting didn't always work. And all the sprockets were damaged with additional scratching occurring after a while. And the rather dubious guarantee which uses the record counter to tell you when its out of guarantee! 200 on counter. I reached 35 on my first two 50 foot reels! And still had nothing worth keeping! I took a long time before I invested in one and knew it had a rather poor reputation. But there were some good reviews so hoped for the best. But alas it fails on thev one job it is design to do and wrecks your films to boot!

Posted by Janice Glesser (Member # 2758) on January 30, 2019, 01:22 PM:

Welcome Richard! If you do a Forum Search for topics such as Telecine, Digital Transfer, Film Transfer, etc. You will see lots of information. Also look at the Technical Topics section:
http://8mmforum.film-tech.com/cgi-bin/ubb/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=1;t=011528

Here's a recent answer I gave to another member wanting to do his own DIY transfers.
http://8mmforum.film-tech.com/cgi-bin/ubb/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=1;t=012695#000006

There are several avenues you could take depending on the equipment you have and your quality expectations.

Posted by Nantawat Kittiwarakul (Member # 6050) on January 30, 2019, 07:47 PM:

No Wolverine&its relatives,please. A too risky investment IMHO. [Eek!]

With roughtly the same amount of money you should try DIY route first. Even off-the-wall projection approach would yield very acceptable result if properly done. You may even get away with that for,say 80% of your 5,000-6,000 ft. Then let the professionals do their job for the important (the rest 20%) part. Hope this helps. [Smile]

Posted by Lee Mannering (Member # 728) on January 31, 2019, 11:58 AM:

Hello Richard. Back in the late 70s dad and I were transferring film to tape merrily. Systems have improved dramatically over the years.

I'm guessing your films are of great value to you so you will Want a good job which reflects this, experience tells me this. Look for a established business that has a pro scanner to deliver a good result which will stand you a lifetime.

The mda or muller are both great machines. Sorry for any typos on a bumpy train

UBB.classic^TM 6.3.1.2