8mm Forum


  
my profile | my password | search | faq | register | forum home
  next oldest topic   next newest topic
» 8mm Forum   » 8mm Forum   » LED projector bulbs ? on the way. (Page 0)

 - UBBFriend: Email this page to someone!  
This topic comprises 3 pages: 1  2  3 
 
Author Topic: LED projector bulbs ? on the way.
Adam Deierling
Jedi Master Film Handler

Posts: 717
From: OH
Registered: Nov 2010


 - posted February 22, 2018 10:25 AM      Profile for Adam Deierling   Email Adam Deierling   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
I am confident that LED technology can work for our projectors but I have yet to figure out the right design. I have tried chips that are rated upwards of 6k-10k lumens and still not able to put more light on screen than the halogen. Its not a matter of fitting the LED in the projector its a matter of focusing the light. Ive spent too much money and time on this. I am no engineer so I will wait for someone smarter than me to figure it out.

I am not trying to discourage anyone from trying. I want you guys to experiment and see if you can figure it out. There is the potential to turn our halogen projectors into xenon equivalents that run on less power and longer lasting bulbs.

 |  IP: Logged

Matthieu van der Sluis
Master Film Handler

Posts: 373
From: Barendrecht, The Netherlands
Registered: Aug 2017


 - posted February 22, 2018 10:42 AM      Profile for Matthieu van der Sluis   Author's Homepage   Email Matthieu van der Sluis   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
I know of people who make lightsaber props and are always searching for brighter LED's.
I myself have replika lightsabers that look as real as possible.

They are using Lenses for making the lightbeam more narrow.
You also nead a heatsink for the LED.
Here is a website that sells stuff they use:
http://www.thecustomsabershop.com/Cree-XP-E2-C136.aspx

 |  IP: Logged

Reid Baron
Junior
Posts: 4
From: Elizabeth, NJ, USA
Registered: Feb 2018


 - posted March 25, 2018 07:16 PM      Profile for Reid Baron   Email Reid Baron   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
Can anyone recommend a suitable replacement LED bulb for a basic editor / viewer, which uses a typical 10 Watt 6 Volt (G3) BA15S Single Contact Bayonet Mount incandescent bulb? The bulb temp should be about 3,000k, which would emit a good white light. Thanks.

 |  IP: Logged

Phil Murat
Jedi Master Film Handler

Posts: 671
From: Villeneuve St Georges, France
Registered: Dec 2015


 - posted March 26, 2018 10:27 AM      Profile for Phil Murat   Email Phil Murat   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
Hello,

May be this is for you :

[URL=https://fr.aliexpress.com/item/Nanoshine-date-P21W-LED-ba15s-1156-led-filament-puce-de-voiture-lumi-re-S25-auto-v/32840441832.html?spm=a2g0w.search0204.3.1.1193756eVSSgQW&s=p& ws_ab_test=searchweb0_0,searchweb201602_3_10152_10151_10065_10344_10068_10342_10343_10340_10341_10696_10084_10083_10618_10305_10304_10307_10306_10302_5711211_10313_10059_10184_1053 4_100031_10103_10624_10623_10622_10621_10620,searchweb201603_25,ppcSwitch_5_ppcChannel&priceBeautifyAB=0]BA15S Led Conversion[/URL]

or

BA15S 6V Conversion

And, of course, only works with DC .....

Let us know

 |  IP: Logged

Brian Fretwell
Phenomenal Film Handler

Posts: 1785
From: London, UK
Registered: Jun 2014


 - posted March 26, 2018 03:57 PM      Profile for Brian Fretwell   Email Brian Fretwell   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
I found this G4 12v LED in Clas Ohlson that looks promising. I have bought one but not tried a conversion yet.

https://www.clasohlson.com/uk/Northlight-G4-LED-Bulb/36-1322

 |  IP: Logged

Alan Gouger
Master Film Handler

Posts: 451
From: Florida
Registered: Jun 2003


 - posted March 26, 2018 04:26 PM      Profile for Alan Gouger   Email Alan Gouger   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
quote:
I am not trying to discourage anyone from trying. I want you guys to experiment and see if you can figure it out. There is the potential to turn our halogen projectors into xenon equivalents that run on less power and longer lasting bulbs.
I have also tried every combination of LED and lens,including a 8000 lumens output setup which was not nearly bright enough. The problen has already been mentioned the light from LED is not focused you would need a custom reflector and lens to capture and focus the light through our tiny S8 gate.

Best option is HID.

 |  IP: Logged

Pere Pasqual
Film Handler

Posts: 43
From: Gandia, València, Spain
Registered: May 2017


 - posted April 17, 2018 10:42 PM      Profile for Pere Pasqual   Author's Homepage   Email Pere Pasqual   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
quote:

I found this G4 12v LED in Clas Ohlson that looks promising. I have bought one but not tried a conversion yet.

https://www.clasohlson.com/uk/Northlight-G4-LED-Bulb/36-1322

I don't know what is going to work, but it's easy to figure out in advance what won't, and this one won't, for obvious reasons. You can see it in the specs:

- Its luminous flux is 100 lm. That's 10% or less of a regular halogen lamp.
- Its power is 1.2 W. No matter how efficient it were, you can clearly imagine that's not going to equal the brightness of a 100 W one.
- There it says also "Equivalent to (incandescent bulb) 10 W". Halogen is far more brighter than an incandescent one at the same wattage, so go figure.

I think that if we are not able to discard these in advance, better refrain from attempting any further experiments. There are already a lot of "potential" candidates that are not going to work anyway to even lose money and effort in the obvious non-working ones...

 |  IP: Logged

Brian Fretwell
Phenomenal Film Handler

Posts: 1785
From: London, UK
Registered: Jun 2014


 - posted April 22, 2018 04:03 PM      Profile for Brian Fretwell   Email Brian Fretwell   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
Sorry I didn't refer back to my earlier post, but this was for a replacement for a 10w editor bulb which is non halogen so it would be an equivalent power. The editor has no reflector, but does have a condenser lens.

 |  IP: Logged

Matthieu van der Sluis
Master Film Handler

Posts: 373
From: Barendrecht, The Netherlands
Registered: Aug 2017


 - posted April 23, 2018 01:48 AM      Profile for Matthieu van der Sluis   Author's Homepage   Email Matthieu van der Sluis   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
Ahh that's interessting indeed.
Let us know how it works.
For now I use van Ecks Halogeen version for my editor, which I think they convert themself.
https://winkel.van-eck.net/SF-0103.html

 |  IP: Logged

Pere Pasqual
Film Handler

Posts: 43
From: Gandia, València, Spain
Registered: May 2017


 - posted June 19, 2018 09:22 AM      Profile for Pere Pasqual   Author's Homepage   Email Pere Pasqual   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
I recently got a couple 100w 12v halogen bulbs and still cyclically stumble upon this issue.

Common sense just doesn't allow me to really believe that this cannot be relatively easy accomplished still in 2018. I've done a fair amount of extra googling and "research" and I've found some counter examples showing that it can be done. Some examples:

- Lego projector. This was already featured in this forum when it was brought to life... which was like 7 years ago! The relevant part here is that it uses an inexpensive flashlight as a light source.

The problem here is that neither a parts list nor detailed building instructions where ever published, and that would be very useful in further attempts, at least to get an idea of the minium lumen output of any flashlight to try. But here there go a couple links to inexpensive flashlights that are supposed to deliver a decent amount of light, they are single-chipped, focusable and, when taken apart from the battery casing, it looks like they would fit inside a projector. You can see many pictures of them in action in the ratings section, uploaded by customers, and they seem to deliver to proper amount of light:

https://www.banggood.com/Elfeland-1201-XM-L-T6-2000LM-5modes-Zoomable-LED-Flashlight-18650AAA-p-1172010.html?rmmds=category&cur_warehouse=CN

https://www.banggood.com/MECO-XM-L-T6-3600LM-Zoomable-LED-Flashlight-2x18650-p-982567.html?rmmds=category&cur_warehouse=CN

[URL]https://www.banggood.com/Astrolux-C8-XP-L-HI-1A-1300Lumens-74modes-A6-Driver-Tactical-EDC-LED-Flashlight-18650-p-1217415.html?rmmds=detail-bottom-alsobought__1&cur_warehouse=C N[/URL]

https://www.banggood.com/MECO-XM-L2-5-Modes-2000LM-Zoomable-LED-Flashlight-p-982520.html?rmmds=category&cur_warehouse=CN

https://www.banggood.com/Elfeland-XM-L-T6-3Modes-2000LM-USB-Rechargeable-Zoomable-LED-Flashlight18650-p-1110220.html?rmmds=category&cur_warehouse=CN

https://www.banggood.com/BLF-A6-XPL-1600LM-7-4modes-EDC-LED-Flashlight-p-991823.html?rmmds=detail-bottom-alsobought__2&cur_warehouse=CN

- Light intensity comparisons for different flashlights. With pictures. This at least shows that the proper amount of light can be obtained by using those kind of flashlights, and they use regular batteries, so to my knowledge it should be possible to attach them to a DC power source, right?

I get lost when trying to do the calculations about the current (in Ampers) that a power source, or the projector itself, would need to provide to the led chip (in fact I don't know the ratings for a 100w 12v halogen lamp); can anyone give some hint on this? But I'm confident it should at least equal the one a couple of standard battteries provide...

These Instructables link may offer some light on that question, though.
Another similar one.

- Replacing an electronic projector bulb with a LED cheap one. Not the best link, but, again, showing that something similar to our goal can be sort of accomplished.

Finally, there's also quite few topics in lightning-related forums here and there (maybe these are the best places to ask for help); not the most useful ones but some hints and ideas can be collected from there:

http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?434464-Su ggestions-on-how-to-replace-projector-bulb-with-an-LED

Waiting for your comments...

 |  IP: Logged

Adam Deierling
Jedi Master Film Handler

Posts: 717
From: OH
Registered: Nov 2010


 - posted June 19, 2018 09:33 AM      Profile for Adam Deierling   Email Adam Deierling   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
The problem is not the availability of intense LEDs to use as projection lamps but the ability to focus the light onto the film frame. The LED flashlights are so intense and yet they are usually small diode LEDs that run off 6 AAs? How is this possible? Reflectors and lenses to focus the beam of light. You need a powerfull LED panel that will fit into a projector and figure out a way to focus it. I would suggest looking into fresnel lenses....

 |  IP: Logged

Pere Pasqual
Film Handler

Posts: 43
From: Gandia, València, Spain
Registered: May 2017


 - posted June 19, 2018 09:41 AM      Profile for Pere Pasqual   Author's Homepage   Email Pere Pasqual   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
But have you seen the video of the Lego projector, Adam? It actually uses a flashlight, and it's a model from 7 years ago...

 |  IP: Logged

Adam Deierling
Jedi Master Film Handler

Posts: 717
From: OH
Registered: Nov 2010


 - posted June 19, 2018 09:44 AM      Profile for Adam Deierling   Email Adam Deierling   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
Yes I have. Again, flashlights focus the light properly for projection. But you can't realistically mount a decent high powered LED flashlight in a GS-1200...

 |  IP: Logged

Pere Pasqual
Film Handler

Posts: 43
From: Gandia, València, Spain
Registered: May 2017


 - posted June 19, 2018 09:56 AM      Profile for Pere Pasqual   Author's Homepage   Email Pere Pasqual   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
quote:

But you can't realistically mount a decent high powered LED flashlight in a GS-1200...

Again, I have to disagree. Have you taken a look at some of the flashlight links I've posted in my last message? The led chip + optics part is really small; less than the size of a 100w, 12v bulb (or a 150w, 24v).

 |  IP: Logged

Adam Deierling
Jedi Master Film Handler

Posts: 717
From: OH
Registered: Nov 2010


 - posted June 19, 2018 10:02 AM      Profile for Adam Deierling   Email Adam Deierling   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
If you disassemble them, sure...but your not going to get anywhere near the light output you will need. That "Lego Projector" is only projecting a few feet. Try projecting 20 feet... But I can see you wont believe me until you see it with you own eyes. So go head and give it a try. I hope you prove me wrong because I would love to have an LED conversion...

 |  IP: Logged

Pere Pasqual
Film Handler

Posts: 43
From: Gandia, València, Spain
Registered: May 2017


 - posted June 20, 2018 01:51 AM      Profile for Pere Pasqual   Author's Homepage   Email Pere Pasqual   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
quote:

If you disassemble them, sure...

Of course, my idea is to try whatever it works. I counted on that from the beginning. Among other reasons because there would be no way to fit a full-sized flashlight inside a projector without disassembling it. My idea is to permanently replace the original bulb without further notice or annoyance for the user, and to connect it to the tension/current source for the halogen bulb.

quote:

but your not going to get anywhere near the light output you will need. That "Lego Projector" is only projecting a few feet. Try projecting 20 feet...

Again, that project is from 7 years ago. LED lightning has evolved in an undescriptable way since them; you cannot compare. You have plenty of models claiming to output thousands of lumens for the price of a halogen bulb. Even if the real amount of light is fake and roughly half the stated, and considering that some percent of light is wasted due to unproper focusing, etc., now we have far more "light power" than 7 years ago.

quote:

But I can see you wont believe me until you see it with you own eyes. So go head and give it a try. I hope you prove me wrong because I would love to have an LED conversion...

I'm determined to at least try the flashlight mod. It looks like the cheapest and easiest attempt. And I don't want to bother or anything. It's that my curious mind finds the urge to at least make some attempt. Of course I confide in your vast experience, Adam, and I'm really taking it into account. It's just that I don't want to give up yet.

My 1st problem now is to decide between the vast amount of models and prizes. That needs some time. Any recommendations welcome!

 |  IP: Logged

Adam Deierling
Jedi Master Film Handler

Posts: 717
From: OH
Registered: Nov 2010


 - posted June 20, 2018 08:24 AM      Profile for Adam Deierling   Email Adam Deierling   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
I wish you nothing but the best. Like I said, I want you (or someone) to succeed in figuring it out. I am simply done wasting money trying to figure out myself...

 |  IP: Logged

Brian Fretwell
Phenomenal Film Handler

Posts: 1785
From: London, UK
Registered: Jun 2014


 - posted June 20, 2018 05:08 PM      Profile for Brian Fretwell   Email Brian Fretwell   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
I suspect really old projectors with condenser lenses rather than "spaceman" lamps or dichroric reflectors would take LED replacements easier.

 |  IP: Logged

Lee McCaffrey
Junior
Posts: 13
From: Newton Abbot, Devon, England
Registered: Jun 2018


 - posted June 21, 2018 04:03 PM      Profile for Lee McCaffrey   Email Lee McCaffrey   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
LG and Optoma/Coretronics have made a number of LED projectors, most of them use 3 high power LEDs and dichroic filters in order to generate the sequential RGB light required for the DMD chip to create the projected image. In the same way a colour wheel modulates the light output from the UHP lamp in conventional DLP projectors, the LEDs in an LED projector pulse rapidly in succession. The pulsing on/off nature allows the LEDs to be overdriven slightly to garner more light output.
I would imagine the LEDs used in these sorts of projectors would be the best match for a modified film projector, filtering as required to obtain the optimum colour spectrum. They could in theory also be programmed to operate as an optical 'shutter' in place of the mechanical shutter.
Digital DLP projectors typically use integrator rods (or lightpipes) to concentrate the light output onto the DMD which in some cases are similar in size to a super 8mm frame. As has been discussed before the problem with LEDs is focussing the light output onto such a small point. Philips has developed HLD (High Lumen Density) ColorSpark LEDs to overcome this 'entendue' effect. These are said to perform much better in digital projectors although as with anything new they are most likely much more expensive.

 |  IP: Logged

Pere Pasqual
Film Handler

Posts: 43
From: Gandia, València, Spain
Registered: May 2017


 - posted June 28, 2018 10:56 AM      Profile for Pere Pasqual   Author's Homepage   Email Pere Pasqual   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
I think this is getting out of control.

Yeah Lee, maybe thos LEDs are wonderful, but I think we don't need to go that far. I've found another video of another person who modded an old projector into using a flashlight:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNE1qBmWfWY

The description says that he's getting more light compared to the original bulb. And, again, that video is from 2014. We are in 2018 and technology has evolved considerable since then regarding LEDs and flashlights. What's seen in this video looks fairly easy to accomplish, and by using a 2000+ "claimed" lumens flashlight I think we should expect at least half that, nearly equal to the halogen rating.

Anyway, I already got one of those flat cheap 10 W LED and plan to attempt some experiments during this weekend. Moreover, I've asked for help in a Spanish LED flashlight forum (there are a number of these on the internet) and I've got already some valueable info. Take a look at these ones:

https://www.fasttech.com/products/0/10031707/7281007-cree-xhp50-2-j4-5a-2654lm -4000k-led-emitter

https://www.fasttech.com/products/0/10032925/7492701-22mm-3000ma-1-mode-dim mable-led-driver-circuit

The 1st one is an XHP50.2, and yeah, these are not "fake" lumens, but "real" ANSI measured ones; the 2nd one is an inexpensive driver which should work with out projectors' bulb 12 V input. The only missing piece is a fan and, maybe, a lens. After some quick googling I found that they at least seem to exist and are suitable for this model of LED, with really narrow beam angles. I have yet to find where to buy them, but let's got step by step: 1st with the flat 10 W LED, then with the XHP50.2 without a lens, and see what happens.

Last but not least: looks like out-of-the-box ready replacements are starting to make their appearance. I cannot remember if we've already talked of these ones:

https://es.aliexpress.com/store/product/Hi gh-lumen-CREE-MR16-LED-spot-light-AC-DC-12V-6W-9W-12W-15W-COB-High/210139_32301397267.html

The one from the left seems almost the needed amount (they say it's a proper replacement for 70 W halogens, and claimed to produce nearly 900 lm), but some kind of of mod should be done in order to mount them inside a projector as there are longer. But you can see they are from the proper connection and tension (12 V DC), and look like our old friend dichroic ones with their and properly "condensed" light beam. They deserve a try at least.

 |  IP: Logged

Lee McCaffrey
Junior
Posts: 13
From: Newton Abbot, Devon, England
Registered: Jun 2018


 - posted June 28, 2018 05:32 PM      Profile for Lee McCaffrey   Email Lee McCaffrey   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
Pere, I wasn't trying to derail the thread or suggest using those particular LEDs, just highlighting what is currently being used in commercial LED projector offerings, and wondering if the principles could be applied to our film projectors.
I agree with you that the most important thing for now is getting something that works, and works well, especially for the projectors out there for which new lamps are becoming scarce/obsolete. The cheaper running costs and longer life would be an extra bonus! Good luck with the trials.

 |  IP: Logged

Pere Pasqual
Film Handler

Posts: 43
From: Gandia, València, Spain
Registered: May 2017


 - posted June 29, 2018 06:18 AM      Profile for Pere Pasqual   Author's Homepage   Email Pere Pasqual   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
Don't worry, Lee. Of course I understand the purpose of your message, and it's very important to be aware of the current state-of-the-art available techonology.

That said, my goal is to try to get results with the already, afordable, available technology, which I suspect is more than enough to achieve, at least, the same performance that with the old halogen bulbs.

I've gone one step forward from my previous message and, instead of trying with XHP50.2, I've already ordered one of these:

https://www.fasttech.com/p/8894801

That's a Cree XHP70.2 6500K LED, capable of outputting up to ¡4292! lumen, with an emitting surface of 7x7 mm, which is slightly more than the size of a 5.79 x 4.01 mm super 8 frame dimensions. Even with a loss of, let's say, 50% light (to exaggerate things to a extreme worst case), that should clearly outperform the lumen amount of an halogen. I've already found 5º narrow focusing lenses on eBay suitable for these type of lead (my goal was to try to use 3º ones, but haven't found any of these yet). I'm not sure if they will be really needed, but due to their cheapness I want to try them anyway to see if it makes a difference.

Now it's just a matter of time to get them and try.

Adam, have you tried any of these leds already?

PS: this is the companion driver I've also ordered

https://www.fasttech.com/p/7217304

which, with it's maximum of 4500 mA, should deliver a bit less than the theoretical maximum rating, but plenty of them anyway.

 |  IP: Logged

Brian Fretwell
Phenomenal Film Handler

Posts: 1785
From: London, UK
Registered: Jun 2014


 - posted June 29, 2018 07:37 AM      Profile for Brian Fretwell   Email Brian Fretwell   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
That lamp looks like it has a lens on it already, it would be interesting to see how the beam spreads from that (ie if it concentrates first then spreads).

Good luck with your project and don't forget the heat sink for the chip.

 |  IP: Logged

Alan Gouger
Master Film Handler

Posts: 451
From: Florida
Registered: Jun 2003


 - posted June 29, 2018 07:38 AM      Profile for Alan Gouger   Email Alan Gouger   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
I have tried several Cree drivers/LED clusters much brighter than what is mentioned here including several flashlights. Unfortunately most of the light does not make it through the film gate. You will need some sort of reflector to capture and redirect the light. I have tried several but have yet to find the right combo.

In theory LED makes sense but of all the alternative light source options avail this is probably the hardest to implement properly. We know it can be done because there are several video projector manufactures offering RGB LED projectors with enough light output to drive a large screen but they have a complicated light path with several custom optics between the LED and lens. Due to the compact nature of S8 projection we have very limited space between the lamp and lens to work with.

It may be more efficient to build a external light box where you can work with the brightest LED cluster and feed the projector with a two foot fiber optic cable, no heat at the projector. There is light loss due to using the fiber optic but it is easily over come if using a brighter LED. The fiber optic is point source and more efficient at delivering the light to the film gate. You now have room to add an optic if need be. Cinema laser projectors are using this method.

 |  IP: Logged

Pere Pasqual
Film Handler

Posts: 43
From: Gandia, València, Spain
Registered: May 2017


 - posted July 02, 2018 02:47 AM      Profile for Pere Pasqual   Author's Homepage   Email Pere Pasqual   Send New Private Message       Edit/Delete Post 
quote:

That lamp looks like it has a lens on it already

I think it's not a lens at all; they call that a "dome"; apparently it's featured in most led chips, and it seems to have some effect in the "halo" or difussion of the projected light; in fact, I've seen they sometimes apply some "mod" to them called "dedoming" - looks like they get some extra amount of light by doing this. But who knows - I haven't investigated it deeply (and probably won't do).

quote:

I have tried several Cree drivers/LED clusters much brighter than what is mentioned here including several flashlights. Unfortunately most of the light does not make it through the film gate. You will need some sort of reflector to capture and redirect the light. I have tried several but have yet to find the right combo.

Maybe the difference is that what I'm attempting here is not a cluster, but a single chip, nearly the size of a 8mm gate, which claims to deliver the stated amount of light. That makes a difference from the usual cluster/array of leds.

And also, as I've said previously, I've ordered a 5º lens also. Looks narrow enough to me. I'm not sure if I can use both a lens and a reflector at the same time with this arrangement. I'll see when I have it in my hands.

quote:

It may be more efficient to build a external light box where you can work with the brightest LED cluster and feed the projector with a two foot fiber optic cable

No idea on how this works. I think this is completely out of my scope...

 |  IP: Logged



All times are Central
This topic comprises 3 pages: 1  2  3 
 
   Close Topic    Move Topic    Delete Topic    next oldest topic   next newest topic
 - Printer-friendly view of this topic
Hop To:

Visit www.film-tech.com for free equipment manual downloads. Copyright 2003-2019 Film-Tech Cinema Systems LLC

Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classicTM 6.3.1.2